Press Releases
WASHINGTON, DC – U.S. Senator Pat Roberts said the proposed health care reform bill would raise taxes on middle class Americans.
“Even though the majority has tried to disguise these taxes as various ‘fees’ and present them as being paid for by targeted health care industries, the reality is that this bill taxes the average American coming and going,” Roberts said on the Senate floor.
The bill calls for nearly $500 billion in new taxes, penalties and fees that hit virtually every American, including middle class families making less than $250,000 and individuals earning less than $200,000. Under this bill, for every one individual or family that benefits from the government subsidy to purchase health insurance, this bill raises taxes on three middle-income individuals and families.
Roberts cited the following examples of tax increases in the bill:
• 40 percent excise tax on health insurance providers that offer high cost health insurance plans. This provision raises $149 billion in taxes and will be paid for in large part through higher income and payroll taxes. By the time this bill is fully implemented, 84 percent of this tax on “high cost plans” will be paid by Americans who earn less than $200,000.
• New taxes on health insurance providers and medical device manufacturers. According to both the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office and Joint Committee on Taxation these taxes will be passed on to consumers in the form of higher insurance premiums. The new $60 billion tax on health insurance providers alone could raise premiums by as much as 2 percent as early as next year.
The $19.3 billion in new taxes on medical devices could increase costs for up to 80,000 medical products such as heart stints, blood pressure monitors, eyeglasses, pacemakers, hearing aids, and advanced diagnostic equipment.
• The floor for deducting medical expenses from income tax is raised from 7.5 percent to 10 percent of adjusted gross income. Those who take this deduction are most often seniors and those with serious or catastrophic medical issues.
For a family of four earning $57,000 in 2013, raising the floor for the deduction means that they would lose a tax deduction of $1,425. A family of four earning $92,000 would lose a tax deduction of $2,300.
• Raises taxes for the more than 35 million Americans who participate in Flexible Spending Accounts, or FSAs. For the first time, the government caps the amount a FSA participant can set aside to pay for health care expenses at $2,500. The typical worker who contributes more than $2,500 to their FSA has a serious medical condition. This means that under this bill, workers with serious illness and earning an average of $55,000 will be paying more in taxes.
Roberts also pointed to an analysis by the non-partisan Joint Committee on Taxation that determined how four tax provisions in the bill, including the deduction for medical expenses and the high cost plans tax will affect Americans:
• When this bill is in full effect, on average, individuals making over $50,000 and families making over $75,000 would see their taxes go up.
• After accounting for the premium tax credit - the subsidy – that the government will provide to help people offset the cost of health insurance, more than 42 million individuals and families, or 25 percent – one quarter– of all tax returns under $200,000 will, on average, see their taxes go up.
“Paying for health care on the backs of middle class, working Americans is the wrong solution for health care and violates the President’s promise to these taxpayers.”
“All Americans, and middle class taxpayers especially, need to take notice of what these higher taxes will mean for them and their families,” Roberts said. “They need to know that these taxes will be used to help pay for a vast expansion of the role of government in health care and more government intrusion into families’ health care choices.”
Senator Roberts is a member of the Senate Committee on Finance, and the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions. He is Co-Chairman of the Senate Rural Health Caucus.
-30-